Here we go! My first review of this new blog. I always have so many thoughts after I watch movies and the 140 character limit on twitter doesn't allow me to express them adequately. Hence, this blog. There likely won't be any sort of schedule for updates. Just whenever I watch a flick and want to comment on it. I don't have a lot of experience writing movie reviews so I'm not sure how well they'll read, they may be kind of rambling at first until I figure out what I'm doing so bare with me. I love discussing movies whether we agree or not so please leave comments and tell me how incredibly wrong I am about the movies I review! Anyway, on with the show
.
WARNING: Here there may be spoilers. Read at your own risk.
I'm going to preface this review by saying that I am a very big fan of the original 2008 Norweigan film "Let The Right One In" of which this film is a remake of so a lot of what I have to say about it will be in comparison with the original. At first I was troubled about so much of my thoughts on this film being coloured by my reaction to the original, but I think that the two films are so similar (even sharing a lot of dialogue) that it's not unreasonable or unfair to compare the two as much as I'm going to.
"Let Me In" is the story of Owen (played by Kodi Smit-McPhee); a young boy tormented at school by a pack of bullies (more about them later) and largely ignored at home by a mother in the midst of a messy divorce (more about this later also.) Owen meets and befriends Abby (played by Chloe Moretz) a "12 year old... more or less" girl who moves in next door. As the two grow closer eventually Owen discovers that she is not a little girl after all, or rather she is, but that's not all she is. She's also a vampire. Spooky. There is also a police detective (played by Ellas Kotteas) investigating the murders that have been committed by the man who lives with Abby (played by Richard Jenkins) in order to supply her with the blood she needs to survive.
This is one of the better remakes of a horror film that I've seen done. Matt Reeves should be commended for "not fixing what isn't broken" for the most part. He maintains much of the atmosphere of the original and makes only very minor changes to the script (he changes 2 characters from the original and creates the character of the policeman who fills the role of one of the absent characters). A great deal of the dialogue is word for word (except for it being in english) the same as the original, as are a lot of the camera shots. They look good. Unfortunately whenever Reeves is doing something different from the original the results aren't quite so good, in fact they are often downright lousy. (A scene in a car is a good example of this.)
I really love that this film wasn't afraid of maintaining the slow pace of the original. My biggest fear going in was that we would lose so much by adding a bunch of ACTION, but Reeves doesn't really do that... ok he does it once or twice and both times it completely fails for me, but apart from two sequences I was very pleased with how restrained it was. Although there are a couple OHMYGODSOMETHINGSCARYJUMPEDOUTATMEANDMADEALOUDNOISE!!! moments (it's a modern american horror flick, of course there is...) for the most part the eerie silence of the original is maintained.
At first I wasn't sure what I thought about the addition of the police officer character replacing the neighbourhood guy in the original. Ellas Kotteas is very good in the role, he's just not given a lot to do.
Chloe Moretz is a excellent. She's almost as good as Lina Leanderson was in the original, which if you've seen the original you'll know is very high praise indeed. She's been the strongest aspect of both movies I've seen her in now (although this is a WAAAAAAYYYYYY better film that Kick Ass. Just sayin) Unfortunately, the movie goes out of its way to remove a lot of the "innocence" the character has in the original by removing a great deal of the ambiguity about her motivation in befriending Owen that there was in the original. The film really goes out of its way to show that she has somewhat ulterior motives for doing so. The beauty of that aspect in the original was how subtle it was, it was much more open to interpretation, this version it gets laid out for you a little too clearly. I was a little disappointed by Smit-McPhee as Owen. He lacked the naive sweetness of the original. He was always either looking mad or just staring with a blank expression, and he really has to carry a lot of the film because it's about him! I found I didn't really care that much about what happened to him (had I not seen Kare Hedebrant in the original I may have been much more impressed).
I worry it sounds like I didn't enjoy this film. That is SO not the case. It's a good movie to be sure, the problem is when you remake a truly great film good doesn't seem as good you know? The majority of my gripes with this version are small nitpicks, however there are a couple things that I think really fall flat that I feel I need to mention.
First, THE SCORE. So much of the atmosphere gets killed when the score starts to swell up to remind us "THIS PART IS SCARY!" It just sounds SO cliche and generic that it really annoyed me. It's just so intrusive and distracting.
Next, THE BULLIES. They are incredibly cliched over the top bad guys. I have trouble believing them for a second. Well at least the lead bully (and his older brother who shows up later) the other two are just props. They do NOTHING in the whole film. They add nothing to any scene that they're in. They just stand there. In the original the two sidekick bullies have limited screen time, and yet they are still interesting characters! These ones aren't characters at all.
Reeves does a good job of showing us how lonely and troubled poor Owen is (even though Smit-McPhee doesn't really) he does such a good job of this with the atmosphere and mood of the movie that the 5 or so minutes he spends showing us what his parents are like feels like an afterthought that is SO unnecessary. We see that the mother is quite emotionally absent from Owen's life (and I LOVE the way Reeves never shows her face clearly. That just worked SO well for me) so the moments where he calls attention to the fact that he's given her an problem with alcohol just feel unnecessary. Then there's a scene where Owen calls his father on the phone and the whole thing just FAILS. The conversation isn't believable to me for a moment. They just feel like really superfluous scenes that weren't needed.
My last major gripe comes at the climax of the film, it really falls into modern horror traps. The music is intense, the lighting is dark and everything is really kinetic (which is SO out of place in a film where much of the action is so static). It completely misses the point of that scene for me. It goes for OMGSCARY and I think it fails at that too.
It feels like there's 2 movies here. One is a slavish remake of the original, the other is standard modern american horror fare. It's quite troubling to me that when Reeves copies the original it works and when he tries something of his own it falls flat.
Overall, I liked this movie. It's quite good. But, if you're only going to watch one of them stick with the original which is great.
I debated whether or not I would bother assigning grades to my reviews on this site, but I think I will if only because after rereading this review it seems pretty negative and I did really like it. So, I will be using a letter grade system here and they will appear at the end of each review.
RATING: B- (and A for the original)